We may receive a commission on purchases made from links.

Very few moments in life have you holding your breath like applying eyeliner.

One wrong flick, and you’re bound to reach for the micellar water and start all over.

Laura Gellar eyeliner, Benefit Roller Liner, Nyx Jumbo eye pencil

That’s why for many, the search forthe best eyelineris deeply personal and can be a lifelong quest.

As such, the right eyeliner has to be committed to me like I am to it.

I tried out 10 top-rated eyeliners in hopes to find a product with seamless system and staying power.

Benefit Roller Liner True Matte Liquid Eyeliner

Five liners remained in my beauty bag, with one becoming a bonfire holy grail in my makeup routine.

If you’re looking for that staple eyeliner to add to your beauty routine, Benefit has you covered.

Roller Liner glides on like butter with a flexible felt tip.

Honest Beauty Longlasting Vegan Liquid Eyeliner

There’s no skips, no dragging, and absolutely no drawbacks to the utility of this product.

This product applies with a punch of pigment off the bat, and dries to a beautiful matte.

Skin and eye sensitivity can throw another wrench into the already difficult search for the perfect eyeliner.

NYX PROFESSIONAL MAKEUP Jumbo Eye Pencil

Free of those pesky irritating ingredients, this is a safe bet for makeup lovers with sensitivities.

Conscious formulation doesn’t mean this eyeliner skimps on performance, either.

Their black jumbo eye pencil is the darkest, boldest black eyeliner of the products I tested.

Physicians Formula Ultra-Fine Liquid Eyeliner

One thing about NYX, they never miss!

I was stunned by this liquid liner’s capabilities at its price point.

It checked all the boxes: seamless, slick system with a flexible applicator.

LAURA GELLER NEW YORK Kajal Longwear Eyeliner

As for its staying power, Physicians Formula lasted through the ultimate eyeliner killer: a heated eyelash curler.

The silver, weighty component even makes this liner feel like a splurge.

This pencil offers a rich, medium-toned brown color payoff with the most subtle shimmer.

It’s uber-blendable upon system but, true to its name, doesn’t budge throughout the day.

BuyLAURA GELLER NEW YORK Kajal Longwear Eyelineron Amazon for $17.Buy on Amazon