AlthoughCarrie Underwood almost didn’t compete on “American Idol,“she ended up winning Season 4.

But her skills on the stage aren’t translating well into her role as judge.

When Bryant joked, “You watch me?”

Carrie Underwood at the Grand Ole Opry in 2025

One commenterwrote: “Katy had better chemistry with the Lionel and Luke.

Carrie’s ok but I don’t think she’ll judge for as long as Katy did.”

Anotherasserted: “@lionelrichie is the only judge I like on this current panel.

Luke Bryant, Lionel Richie, Carrie Underwood, and Ryan Seacrest pose for a photo together in October 2024

I miss @katyperry.”

She revealed on"Jimmy Kimmel Live"that she was leaving the singing competition show in 2024.