Taylor Swift has dated quite a few famous faces.

Boys Like Girls frontman Martin Johnson.

That chatter only grew stronger thanks to Taylor’s mom, Andrea Swift.

Martin Johnson and Taylor Swift singing together

According toInside Edition, that guy was Johnson.

That’s around the time she and Johnson were supposedly hanging out.

All of them!"

Martin Johnson and Taylor Swift side by side

She’s one of the most talented songwriters to work with, if not the best.

For such a young girl, she’s so creative and spot-on."

But it sounds like things may have broken down from there.

Martin Johnson and Taylor Swift performing

Though Tisdale didn’t explicitly confirm its title, it was more than likely “Love Story.”