Carrie Underwood performs at Times Square…
Unfortunately, commentators had myriad issues with her vocal talents too.
In fact, one user even compared it to Lara Trump’s hilariously off-key performance at Mar-a-Lago.

Meanwhile, other users tried to come up with valid reasons for Underwood’s arguably poor performance.
In typical fashion,Underwood couldn’t escape plastic surgery rumorsafter the dodgy performance either.
One criticwondered aloud, “Damn Carrie Underwood, wtf did you do to your face?”

and asserted that she may have used Botox.
Even back then, people speculated that the fall was a cover story for a plastic surgery scar.