Although Colbert initially geared up to do his usual schtick with Keith, he had a change of heart.

Instead, the comedian thought to himself, “‘Make him feel welcome.

See who he is.'”

Toby Keith Stephen Colbert smiling cowboy hats

When Colbert decided to go with that approach, the men got along well and had a great conversation.

Whatever the f*** it is you do."

He implored his audience to keep that in mind.

Toby Keith Stephen Colbert grasping hands

The comedian ended his homage with a nickname for Keith: “Thank you, Big Dog.”